back to articles

Home Service Contract Company Comparison: American Home Shield

Which Home Service Contract Company Comes Out On Top When You Compare?

When it comes to comparing home service contracts and home service contract companies, it is helpful to first start with categories to compare them by.

These are the three "c's" we accounted for in our home service contract company comparison:

  • Customer Service
  • Coverage
  • Cost

After comparing the home service contract companies in these three categories, and taking into consideration reviews left on HomeWarrantyReviews.com, Yelp and Google, we then compared the top four home service contract companies – to each other.

Here are the comparison results:

Home Service Contract Company Comparison No.1:
Choice Home Warranty vs. American Home Shield

1. Customer Service Comparison

BBB Rating

NHSCA Member

Choice Home Warranty

C+

No

American Home Shield

B

Yes

In the customer service comparison of Choice Home Warranty versus American Home Shield, American Home Shield comes out on top with a better rating by the BBB, and an active membership with the National Home Service Contract Association (NHSCA), a non-profit industry trade organization of member companies serving home service contract providers and consumer interests throughout the United States.

2. Coverage Comparison

Coverage Area

Plan Options

Choice Home Warranty

Select States

Multiple

American Home Shield

Select States

Multiple

In the coverage comparison of Choice Home Warranty versus American Home Shield, the results are a draw. Neither company has nationwide coverage, although both provide coverage in most states. Choice Home Warranty and American Home Shield both also have multiple plan options, including combo plans and flexible option plans where homeowners can select add-ons to include in their home service contract.

3. Cost Comparison

Premium

Deductible

Choice Home Warranty

$370.00 – $450.00

$60.00

American Home Shield

$299.00+

$75.00+

In the cost comparison of Choice Home Warranty versus American Home Shield, the results are also a draw. Both have plan options that span the cost spectrum, and although American Home Shield plans start at a lower premium amount, their deductibles are higher.

Choice Home Warranty vs. American Home Shield

By narrow margins, American Home Shield comes out on top in the comparison of Choice Home Warranty versus American Home Shield.

For more quote comparison information on Choice Home Warranty and American Home Shield, continue your research on CompareHomeWarrantyQuotes.com.

Home Service Contract Company Comparison No.2:
American Home Shield vs. Old Republic Home Protection

1. Customer Service Comparison

BBB Rating

NHSCA Member

American Home Shield

B

Yes

Old Republic Home Protection

A+

Yes

In the customer service comparison of American Home Shield versus Old Republic Home Protection, Old Republic Home Protection comes out on top with a better rating by the BBB, and an active membership with the NHSCA.

2. Coverage Comparison

Coverage Area

Plan Options

American Home Shield

Select States

Multiple

Old Republic Home Protection

Select States

Multiple

In the coverage comparison of American Home Shield versus Old Republic Home Protection, the results are a draw. Neither company has nationwide coverage, but both have multiple plan options.

A side comparison fact to keep in mind when comparing these two companies is their extensive experience in providing home service contracts; both companies have been in business for over 40 years.

3. Cost Comparison

Premium

Deductible

American Home Shield

$299.00+

$75.00+

Old Republic Home Protection

$260.00+

$55.00+

In the cost comparison of American Home Shield versus Old Republic Home Protection, Old Republic Home Protection comes out on top with slightly better pricing on their premiums and lower starting deductible costs.

American Home Shield vs. Old Republic Home Protection

Both American Home Shield and Old Republic Home Protection are very good home service contract companies. With a narrow win, Old Republic Home Protection comes out on top in this comparison. With nearly 100 years of experience between these two companies, both are a great option as a home service contract company.

For more quote comparison information on American Home Shield and Old Republic Home Protection, continue your research on CompareHomeWarrantyQuotes.com.

Home Service Contract Company Comparison No.3:
American Residential Warranty vs. American Home Shield

1. Customer Service Comparison

BBB Rating

NHSCA Member

American Residential Warranty

A+

No

American Home Shield

B

Yes

In the customer service comparison of American Residential Warranty versus American Home Shield, the results come down to having, or not having, an active membership with the NHSCA, which American Residential Warranty does not.

Both companies have exceptionally good ratings according to the BBB, but at CompareHomeWarrantyQuotes.com we take a membership with the NHSCA to be a clear indicator of those companies adhering to industry best practices, with a commitment to providing customers with the best when it comes to home service contracts.

2. Coverage Comparison

Coverage Area

Plan Options

American Residential Warranty

Select States

Multiple

American Home Shield

Select States

Multiple

In the coverage comparison of American Residential Warranty versus American Home Shield, the results are a draw in this comparison category. Neither company has nationwide coverage, although both provide coverage in most states. American Residential Warranty and American Home Shield both also have multiple plan options, including bundle plans, appliance-specific plans and upgrade options in between.

3. Cost Comparison

Premium

Deductible

American Residential Warranty

$400.00+

$50.00

American Home Shield

$299.00+

$75.00+

In the cost comparison of American Residential Warranty versus American Home Shield, American Home Shield comes out on top. Despite having a slightly higher starting deductible, American Home Shield premiums are over $100.00 cheaper. American Residential Warranty's premiums are also some of the most expensive in home service contract plans.

American Residential Warranty vs. American Home Shield

In another close comparison, American Home Shield comes out on top, however so slightly, in the American Residential Warranty versus American Home Shield company comparison.

Closing Remarks on Home Service Contract Company Comparisons

Nothing compares to having a home service contract and a home service contract company you can count on – especially when you need them.

And while this is our comparison, we encourage families to consider local and national providers and to conduct their own home service contract company comparison complete with categories that are important to them.

Home Service Contract Resources: